A tragic incident occurred on the Hollow Water First Nation in Manitoba, where a man identified as Tyrone Simard, 26, fatally stabbed his sister and injured several others on September 4, 2025. Following the attack, Simard fled the scene in a stolen vehicle, leading police on a pursuit that ended in a crash with an officer responding to the incident. Simard was killed in the collision, while the officer sustained critical injuries but is reportedly expected to recover.
This violent event not only left the community mourning but also evoked memories of a similar mass stabbing that took place three years prior on the James Smith Cree Nation in Saskatchewan, which resulted in 11 fatalities and 17 injuries. The longstanding impact of violence within Indigenous communities is poignantly highlighted through this recurrence.
In response to the incident, various leaders and representatives expressed their condolences and support for the Hollow Water First Nation community. Manitoba Premier Wab Kinew remarked, “To the leadership and to the community members of Hollow Water, our hearts are with you. Our hearts feel very heavy, and we will be there to support you in the ways that are necessary.” This statement reflects a commitment to not only empathize with the grieving community but to offer tangible support during times of crisis.
Chief Larry Barker of the Hollow Water First Nation urged community members to come together in prayer and support as they navigate through the challenging aftermath of the attack. He expressed his thoughts and prayers for those recovering in the hospital, emphasizing the necessity of communal solidarity in healing.
A statement from the James Smith Cree Nation conveyed a message of solidarity, stating, “We know the weight of loss, and we stand with them in solidarity during their time of grief. From our Nation to theirs, we send strength, compassion, and the reminder that they are not alone.” This sentiment highlights a shared experience of loss among Indigenous communities, reinforcing connections during tragedy.
Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe noted the timing of the attack, acknowledging its impact on the province. He mentioned, “The attack today comes during a difficult time that affected people across our province ... we pause to honour the lives lost, stand with the families who continue to grieve, and reflect on the path of healing that continues for so many.” This reflects the broader social implications of such violence, extending beyond just the immediate victims.
Federal leaders also voiced their concerns and solidarity with the Hollow Water community. Rebecca Alty, Canada’s minister of Crown-Indigenous relations, expressed deep heartbreak regarding the situation, while Mandy Gull-Masty, Canada’s minister of Indigenous services, stated her heart was with all affected individuals. Gary Anandasangaree, Canada’s public safety minister, also acknowledged the supportive efforts of the RCMP in responding to the immediate needs of those victimized in the attack.
The National Police Federation, representing RCMP officers, highlighted the dangers faced by law enforcement while serving communities, stating their solidarity with RCMP members in Manitoba and the Hollow Water First Nation amidst tragedy. Winnipeg Centre MP Leah Gazan also expressed her devastation over the incident, reaffirming her support for the community during this difficult time.
Lastly, Kyra Wilson, Grand Chief of the Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs, stated, “We stand with Hollow Water in this moment of grief and uncertainty. Our thoughts and prayers are with those who were harmed, and the Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs is prepared to support the community in every way needed.” This commitment signifies an important recognition of the ongoing need for support and care within affected communities, particularly in light of their historical experiences with violence.
