In late 2025, approximately 2,600 foreign workers who had applied for permanent residency through the Ontario Immigrant Nominee Program (OINP) were notified that their applications were either rejected or returned. This decision stemmed from concerns raised by the province regarding fraudulent activities and systemic misrepresentation associated with the applications. Consequently, around 300 of the affected workers initiated a court challenge against the Ministry of Labour, seeking a review of their applications on an individual basis.
On a recent Monday night, those workers achieved a significant victory when two judges from the Ontario Superior Court of Justice ruled in their favor, affirming their right to have their applications considered. However, a third judge dissented from this decision. The ruling highlighted that at the time of application submission, the Director did not possess the authority to return complete applications without making a decision. According to the relevant regulation, there was an obligation for the Director to make a determination regarding whether to grant the application once it was deemed complete.
In June 2025, the Ministry implemented a new regulation that allowed for the return of applications without a decision due to systemic concerns about fraud. However, the applicants contended that this new regulation did not override their statutory right to receive a decision on completed applications. Two out of the three judges agreed with this viewpoint. They stated, "I would allow the applications for judicial review and remit the applicants' applications to the Director to be determined in accordance with the process in place prior to the regulatory change." This establishes a legal precedent regarding the processing of immigration applications in Ontario.
Andres Pelenur, Managing Partner at Borders Law Firm and counsel for three of the OINP applicants, expressed that the court's ruling confirms that the province of Ontario cannot arbitrarily alter the rules governing applicants who have complied with the OINP program's requirements. He emphasized that the clients, having worked a full year in a skilled trade in Ontario, were invited to apply under the OINP program and were informed that their applications were complete. This situation entitled them to a final decision on their applications, thus making the OINP's decision to retroactively cancel the entire stream a violation of established law as defined by the Supreme Court of Canada.
While the court's order directly applies only to the applicants who appeared in court, the reasoning has broader implications for the entire pool of 2,600 affected individuals who experienced the same issue with their applications being summarily returned without a final decision. Pelenur expressed satisfaction with the court's well-reasoned majority decision, indicating its significance beyond just the immediate case.
According to the information available on the Ministry's website, the OINP is responsible for nominating individuals for permanent residency who possess the necessary skills and experience required by the Ontario economy. The final decision regarding applications for permanent residency lies with the Government of Canada.
Immigration consultant Kanwar Sierah celebrated the court ruling, labeling it as a "landmark case in Ontario's immigration history." He emphasized that the ruling mandates the reopening of applications for individual assessments, rather than default approvals for all applicants. Sierah noted that this landmark decision carries with it a fine of $20,000 imposed on the Ontario Government, marking a significant moment in the realm of immigration policy within the province.




