The Toronto Police Service Homicide Unit has demonstrated remarkable success in solving murders throughout the city, with an overall clearance rate averaging nearly 80 percent since 1921. However, despite this achievement, the unit continues to grapple with numerous cold cases, including the long-unsolved homicide of 21-year-old Margaret McWilliam.
Margaret McWilliam disappeared on August 27, 1987, after leaving her home located near St. Clair and Warden in Scarborough for a routine run. Tragically, she was found deceased the following day, having been discovered in a secluded area of Warden Woods Park by officers from 41 Division, assisted by the Peel Regional Canine Unit. Detective Constable Andrew Doyle, who is currently investigating the case, confirmed that her body was located in a heavily wooded section of the park.
Margaret's killer has never been apprehended, a fact that continues to weigh heavily on her family. Her mother, Charlotte McWilliam, now in her 80s, remains resolute in her search for justice and seeks answers regarding her daughter’s brutal murder. “It was a terrible thing. He just can’t get away with it,” Charlotte expressed, voicing her enduring pain and hope for closure.
Detective Constable Doyle emphasized that they possess the killer’s DNA profile but are still in need of a name to move forward with the investigation. “I need a name. We’ll do the rest. I still believe there is someone out there, maybe more than one person, who knows exactly what happened to Margaret,” stated Doyle, indicating that the investigation remains active and urging the public for any potential leads.
This tragic case has been highlighted as one of the focal points in the new season of “Tracking a Killer: The Cold Case Files,” a podcast that aims to shed light on unsolved homicides. The first episode of this season is now available on the Frequency Podcast Network, drawing attention to cases like that of Margaret McWilliam and the persistent efforts of the Toronto Police Homicide Unit to seek justice.
Listeners can also access the podcast episode on Spotify.
In summary, the ongoing investigation into the murder of Margaret McWilliam serves as a chilling reminder of unresolved cases that still demand public attention and involvement. The support of the community could prove instrumental in bringing justice to Margaret and her grieving family, reinforcing the importance of collective efforts in solving such heartbreaking crimes.
